#REVIEW: Mortal Shell 2 (PS5, 2026)

The tl;dr verdict: A clear improvement over the original, but somehow still an 8/10.

It has somehow been over six years since Mortal Shell came out a few months ago, and the sequel won the Which Do I Play First sweepstakes over Onimusha and Phantom Blade Zero, since I only play Soulslikes and games with samurai in them nowadays. And you should play it! You should especially play it if you beat the first game, since it keeps all of the first game’s strengths and switches to an Elden Ring-esque open world full of dungeons and castles and way more variety in terrain and look than the first game had. There’s also a ton more customizability available than there was in the first game; I think easily 3/4 of the players of Mortal Shell ended up using the same weapon and the same shell by the end of the game, because they were overwhelmingly superior choices. If they weren’t it was because they were specifically avoiding using the same shell and weapon that everyone else was playing with. There are not an unlimited number of upgrade materials, although there’s a fair amount of ways to respec your character and weapons, so you will still probably end up settling on a character and a weapon rather than doing a lot of swapping around, but there are a lot more viable builds in this game than in the previous one. A lot more. You also pick up a sidearm (several available choices) and a few different defense choices that weren’t in the first game, although I ended up sticking with the turn-yourself-to-stone Harden ability from the first game rather than playing with either of the parry-based options.

(That’s Proxima with the Obsidian Hammer up there, which ended up being my choice for 80% of the game; the hammer is widely not considered to be one of the best weapons, but my God did I fall in love with the big-bonk style for this one.)

I have no real technical complaints; the game looks, sounds, and feels great, in a way that is superior to the original across the board. I did hit a hard crash once or twice but never lost anything significant because of them.

So why an 8/10? Insanely inconsistent difficulty, that’s why. The prologue of the game starts you off with a fairly tough shell, but you lose access to it at the end of the prologue, and you never get it back. After the prologue you start off with no shell at all, meaning you’re in your incredibly squishy Harbinger body until you find another one, and it’s not like they’re right next door or anything like that. This means that after the first hour of the game or so you’re going to be in a body that’s going to die in a hit or two from nearly anything, with very little healing, in a game that’s balanced for you to be able to die twice instead of once (once that knocks you out of your shell, which you can get back, and the second that actually kills you if you don’t regain your shell) before you’re forced to respawn at a beacon, which is this game’s equivalent of the traditional Dark Souls bonfires.

I called this “one of the hardest games I’ve ever played” early on, and I wasn’t kidding. Now, once you find a shell and a weapon you’re vibing with, it gets hugely easier– if anything, I found that the build I’d chosen plus an item that gives you access to a summon made most of the bosses first-try trivial– but I spent a couple of days getting killed left and right, and even once I found a shell, the first one you’re likely to encounter is one of the squishier ones and combined with one of the faster, less-damaging weapons from that part of the game, I was still getting killed a lot. If you’re new to these types of games, I can imagine a whole lot of players just giving up rather than pushing through to where things get easier.

There are also occasional points in the game where the difficulty level is gonna shoot through the roof for a little while just because of the situation the game puts you into. If you’re enough of an OG that the phrase “the silver knight archers at Anor Londo” causes your blood pressure to spike, you should be aware that there are enemies in this game with ballista for heads and they absolutely fucking suck. And do they tend to throw them at you in places where being sent flying by their arrows will knock you off a cliff to your doom?

Yes. Yes, of course they do.

(A strength I haven’t mentioned: the enemy and boss design is stellar. Exploding baby demons. Bearded, four-legged jumping skulls. Spiders with corpses dangling from their middles. The aforementioned ballista-heads suck but they look awesome. One boss is basically a mouth attached to a digestive tract and he will literally try to poop you to death. He is called “The Lost Child,” which given that a different boss is called the “Malborn Offspring,” is kind of hilarious.)

The other place where the difficulty really shot up was the final boss, but now that I’ve beaten him (after a couple of hours of trying) I’m willing to admit that his difficulty might have been at least partially from a mismatch with my build. I don’t think a slow-bonk style is great against Zmey the Unbidden, is what I’m saying. I do love that I took him out on the very next fight after telling my wife that for the first time in a long time I thought I’d hit a boss I couldn’t beat.

But I did. So ha.

Anyway, you want to play this if your taste matches mine at all, but you definitely don’t want it to be your first try at this type of game. But if you’re used to Soulslikes? Go for it, just gird your loins for those first couple of hours.


Discover more from Welcome to infinitefreetime dot com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply